Amityville Historical Sites


Constructed in 1892, The Triangle Building stands in the center of the village on land that was previously a picnic grove.

At one point the small tower was removed fromt the building because the owner at the time felt that it was in need of extensive repair.

The Amityville Trotting Association Racetrack was a harness-racing track on the west side of North Broadway beyond Marilyn Avenue. The track was financed in 1895 by a number of prominent village residents.

Amityville resident Gilbert P. Williams drives the Best Tracy, who raced in Amityville between 1895 and 1900.

About two dozen men and women pose with Lawrence Sperry's airplane, which was based at Unqua Place in Amityville in the 1920's.
Once a summer resort, Amityville attracted families who wanted to escape the crowds and the heat of the city. Several grand hotels were built along the Great South Bay, the most famous of which was Hotel New Point. Local carpenters from Haff, Ketchum, Purdy, Sprague, Smith, Wasner, Weed and Wicks families helped to build New Point. The hotel was three and a half stories high and had 60 guest rooms, a large veranda, a bathing beach with bathhouses and a carriage house. It was a scheduled stagecoach stop on the Powell Livery schedule from the Amityville Railroad Station. In 1916, an auction was conducted to sell the contents of the hotel. Afterward the building was used for fund-raisers and as a camp – first the New York Herlad Tribune Fresh Air Camp and the, in its last days, the Meroke Day Camp.


Amityville was home to four hospitals – unusual for a small community. Louden Hall Psychiatric Hospital was established by the Louden family in 1886.

Originally the Bank of Amityville and then merging with the Franklin National Bank of Long Island. And Finally on 1971 Franklin National gifted the building to the Amityville Historical Society. The historical society is still located here today.

Built in 1867, the Amityville Railroad Station is shown here while the Huntington-Amityville Trolley crosses the viaduct in the distance.

Narrasketuck sailboats race on the Great South Bay. On the shore are the Hathaway Inn (left) and Hotel New Point. The Narrasketuck sailboat was designed by Wilbur Ketchum. The Ketchums were well-known boatbuilders in the area.


Amityville High School is pictured here in 1894. At the time, it had only six high school students. After 1924, the building became an elementary school.
Houses of Amityville
"George Washington Supped Here". On April 21, 1790, during his tour of Long Island, Washington "dined at one Ketchums", which he described in his diary as a "very neat & decent public House". Washington's repast was taken at Zebulon Ketcham's Inn, the located on Merrick Road. In the 1940's, the inn was transported by barge down Ketcham's "Crik" and reestablished as a residence on Bayview Avenue at Purdy Lane. Washington's portrait graces the mantel over the dining room hearth to this day.
This famous house poses classical elements of the Dutch Colonial design including a gambrel roof, shingled siding and a side entry. The Dutch style recalls an early colonial building technique, in which houses were constructed laterally to accommodate narrow lots. Built around 1925 by Jesse Purdy, a premiere house builder, this house lies on the Amityville River, nestled next to the Ireland homestead. Recently associated with a book and movie, this house is better remembered as the house with Amityville's smallest lawn.

Will Rogers – a cowboy, humorist, Ziegfeld Follies star and everyday philosopher – called Amityville home is the early 1920s. An astute commentator, Rogers "never met a man he didn't like". He lived in this 1895 Queen Anne home on Clocks Boulevard, across from the Vaudevillian Fred Stone. It was here that Roger dove off Stone's dock into the Narrasketuck Crik and broke his neck. Long days of rest in Amityville sharpened his wit and his roping. A regular at Losi's Confectionary, Rogers could be seen chatting with neighbors, exclaiming, "all I know is what I read in the papers".
Surrounded by myth and legend, sharpshooter Annie Oakley (1860-1926) enjoyed a long career as a vaudeville entertainer and friend to fellow Amityvillians Will Rogers and Fred Stone. In the early 1920s, she rented this home on the east side of Ocean Avenue, built in the American Foursquare style. In the late 1920s, the house was altered by removing the porch and adding symmetrical wings. Commanding a prominent place along the river, the house lies atop Bennett's Hill, a slight rise marking the beginning of salt hay meadows..
Learn more about Amityville's History
Images of America presents Amityville
Come visit our Museums Salt Hay Gift Shop to get your copy of this wonderful book. Filled with images and fun facts about Amityville's glorious past.

Amityville History Book

 

Historical House Tours

The Amityville Historical Society hosts tours of the village homes and sites. Learn about the Historical Homes and Notable Persons from Amityvilles past and present.

Call for more info (631) 598-1486